9/2/25

Inspiration vs. Direct Copying: Why One Builds Your Brand and the Other Breaks It

Let’s be real for a second — there’s no such thing as creating in a vacuum.
Every single one of us has seen something online, in a store, or in nature that made us go:
"Dang… I want to make something like that!"

That feeling is inspiration. It’s natural. It’s powerful. It’s what fuels creativity.
But there’s a fine line between taking inspiration and outright copying — and the two have wildly different outcomes for your reputation, your growth, and your business.

---

What Inspiration Actually Is

Inspiration is when something sparks your imagination — a color palette from a sunset, a font pairing from a coffee shop menu, the mood of a vintage ad. You take those sparks, add your own style, your own elements, and your own thought process, and you build something new.

It’s like cooking — you might use a recipe as a starting point, but you season it your own way, swap ingredients, and add a twist until it’s a dish only you could make.

When you create from inspiration, you’re not just making a product — you’re making something that feels authentic to your brand and your customers. And authenticity? That’s what people remember.

---

What Copying Actually Is

Copying is when you take someone’s completed design, change one or two small things (or sometimes nothing at all), and claim it as your own.

Let me be blunt — changing the font color, swapping one word, or moving an element a few pixels to the left isn’t designing. That’s duplication.

And sure, you might get a quick sale from it. But here’s what you’ll lose:

• Trust from your customers once they notice it’s not original.

• Respect from other creators in your community.

• Opportunities for real collaborations because your reputation is damaged.

In business, your name is everything. Once people start whispering, “Oh, they just copy other people’s stuff”, it’s almost impossible to get that trust back.

---

The Ripple Effect No One Talks About

Direct copying doesn’t just hurt the original creator. It hurts the entire creative ecosystem.

Think about it — if you see your design duplicated and sold for less, you might feel discouraged, pull back from creating, or stop releasing certain products altogether. Multiply that by hundreds of designers, and suddenly the entire community is producing less.

When we all create authentically, the industry grows. When we all copy, the creativity dries up.

---

How to Draw the Line in Your Own Work

Here’s how to make sure you’re staying on the “inspiration” side of the line:

1. Start with a Spark, Not a Screenshot
   If you love a design you saw, figure out why you love it. Is it the mood? The texture? The typography? Take that one element and build something completely different around it.

2. Pull From Multiple Sources
   Don’t just look at one piece. Mix three or more influences — a color scheme from Pinterest, a pattern from nature, and a layout idea from an old magazine ad. The result will be uniquely yours.

3. Test the “Show & Tell” Rule
   Ask yourself: Would I feel confident showing this to the original creator? If the answer is “uhhh… probably not,” then you know it’s too close.

4. Make It Impossible to Reverse-Engineer
   If someone can look at your design and immediately point to the exact design you started from, you didn’t transform it enough.

---

When Inspiration Turns Into Growth

Here’s the magic — when you focus on creating from inspiration instead of duplication, you start to develop a style that’s recognizable as yours.

Customers will begin to say:
"I knew that was a Geez Louise design the second I saw it!"

That’s branding. That’s what brings repeat buyers. And that’s what allows you to charge what your work is worth instead of constantly competing on price.

---

The Bottom Line

Inspiration pushes you forward. Copying keeps you stuck.
When you take the easy way out by duplicating someone else’s work, you rob yourself of the chance to grow as a designer and business owner.

So next time you see a design you love, don’t ask:
"How can I make that exact thing?"
Ask:
"How can I take the feeling this gives me and turn it into something only I could make?"

Because at the end of the day, the world doesn’t need another watered-down version of someone else’s design.
It needs you — your ideas, your spin, your voice.